“Recipient of 3 nominations for the 2009-10 Drama Desk Awards”
— Drama Desk
“Presented with wall-rattling glee...deliciously watchable”
— The New York Times
“Cheslik-DeMeyer and Maner’s lyrics effortlessly mix irony, sincerity and poetry”
— CurtainUp
“We came for splattered red, for madness and mayhem, and Lizzie Borden more than delivers”
— Show Business Weekly
“4 stars—A fetching, brawny rock musical”
— Time Out NY
“Brazen, rambunctious production”
— Backstage
“A tongue-in-cheek murderous romp”
— Feminist Review
“Forty whacks to anyone who misses it”
— Blogcritics Culture
“The most fun I've had in the theatre in a long time”
— Pataphysical Science
“An incredible evening of theatre... I recommend it to EVERYONE!”
— Stefani Koorey of Mondo Lizzie
“Can they rock!”
— Show Showdown
“I have already made plans to attend again”
— Shadowtime NYC